This eyeliner is quite amazing. Let me break down the pros and cons.
- Super black
- Stays put like gel liner
- Super creamy and soft
- Twist up (no sharpening)
- Does not smudge
- Twist up thing doesn’t work too well (sometimes I have to keep twisting and twisting)
- Only twists up, not down
- The tip gets blunt so its hard to draw a fine line
Overall, I quite like the eyeliner. The product itself is good, although the application is a little messy. It is just like using a gel liner, without the trouble of using a separate gel liner and brush and having to clean the brush, or have the gel liner dry out.